Skip to content

Brent Johner

Author, Reviewer, Critique Partner

Menu
  • Home
  • About
    • My Novels
    • NOAH
    • THE LAST COFFLE
    • STRANGE MS.
  • Readers
    • Read Free
    • Reader FAQ
    • How Toโ€ฆ
    • Newsletter
  • Critique
    • Critique Partners
    • Critique Options
    • Dev Edits
    • Registration
    • Login
  • Contact Me
  • More
    • Colleagues
    • Editors
    • Policies
Menu
Book Cover

Review – Gardens of the Moon

Posted on November 2, 2026

A Voice & Vibe Book Review

๐บ๐‘Ž๐‘Ÿ๐‘‘๐‘’๐‘›๐‘  ๐‘œ๐‘“ ๐‘กโ„Ž๐‘’ ๐‘€๐‘œ๐‘œ๐‘›. Steven Erikson. 1999. 

Canadian literature. Military fantasy. Epic fantasy. High fantasy. Dark fantasy. First book of the Malazan Book of the Fallen series. 

When a ruthless Empress targets her own troops for elimination during a brutal war, a demoted sergeant and a young nobleman are forced to navigate deadly internal politics and meddling gods to survive the conquest of a legendary citadel.

This is a polyphonic military fantasy shared by as many as 33 point-of-view characters, depending on how you count them. The narrative distance varies from close to limited and omniscient. And there is quite a bit of genuine head hopping. 

All of the world building comes through context clues, beginning in the opening scene when the reader is dumped into the chaos of a battlefield littered with the dead. This method of storytelling creates a dark, disorienting vibe that is akin to waking up in the middle of a nightmare.

The stream of information coming at the readerโ€”names, ranks, roles, relationships, plans, places, eventsโ€”flows with the ferocity of a firehose. Although I am an experienced reader, I had trouble following the story, even with the help of three different wiki chapter guides published by the seriesโ€™ fandom.  

AUTHORS – I write short book reviews that focus on voice and vibe. They are useful to querying authors searching for comp titles. There are more like this on my website.

Tags

book review, Canadian literature, dark fantasy, epic fantasy, high fantasy, military fantasy, Patrick Walsh, Steven Erikson

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Categories

  • Book Reviews
  • Noah
  • The Last Coffle

Recent Posts

  • Review – A Feast for Crows
  • Review – Gardens of the Moon
  • Review – Inversion
  • Review – The Wettest County in the World
  • Review – Yellow Wife

Recent Tags

apocalyptic fiction Appalachian fiction book review Canadian literature coming-of-age Cormac McCarthy country noir crime story Daniel Woodrell dark fantasy dark gothic fantasy debut DHH Literary Ellen Levine epic fantasy fantasy George R. R. Martin high fantasy historical fiction Holly Root horror Kirby McCauley literary fiction Melanie Jackson Melanie Jackson Agency memoir middle grade neo-noir neo-Western new adult nonfiction parody Percival Everett Root Literary Ryan David Jahn sci-fi self-published short stories Southern gothic spy thriller thriller Trident Literary Group urban fantasy V. E. Schwab young adult

©2026 Brent Johner | Design: Newspaperly WordPress Theme